Real Reviews. Authentic Experiences.

Good breakfast deals.

Arrived a little early, and our room wasn't ready. Okay. Sitting in the crowded lobby. Q: Can we get a bottle of water? A: No, only free water in your room.

If it wasn't for the very good quality of service from staff, I would not rate the Edison this highly. Heather in housekeeping on the 15th floor, Julia and Rich at Bonds in the basement, and Sam the lady server at Friedman's were all exceptional. The room was clean, basic, and renovated. Nothing special, but nothing to complain about. If the rates were more aligned with regular market pricing, this would be very good value. Unfortunately, I fell prey to insane rip-off pricing during fashion week and the UN session. Worse yet, I specifically called to speak with someone and ensure that I could book a renovated room. That person told me that "all the rooms are the same." Upon arriving, I was lectured on how I should know better; that a "Signature" room is renovated and a "Classic" is not. I then had the privilege of paying an additional $300 for the room. Also the "complimentary" breakfast is your choice or grab-n-go or a very limited selection from Friedman's Restaurant. Both are "okay" but know that your selections are very limited and there's a token $5.00 payment you need to make for sit-down service at Friedman's. Lastly, a pleasant surprise was the fitness center. It's nothing lavish or particularly exciting, but it's far better equipped than the photos on the website and is on par or better than most hotel gyms.